• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Book
  • Insurance Background
  • Resources
  • Contact Me

Carrie Reynolds

carrie-reynolds-insurance-goddess

July 16, 2011 by Carrie Reynolds 1 Comment

“Selling” social media to a skeptic

I had an amazing experience recently- another insurance professional, whom I did not know, called me out of the blue to discuss my usage of social media. Pretty brave of him really, but almost an hour later we were talking like old friends.
Here’s the kicker- he has absolutely nothing to do with social media.

He stumbled across an article I wrote for American Agent & Broker recently (shameless plug) called “4 Strategies to Avoid the Social Media Time Drain.” He said, and I quote, “The Internet leads I subscribe to are drying up and I’m looking for new ways to bring in business.” Fair enough- aren’t we all really? He was intrigued by the article and wanted to discuss how social media might help him. He warned me he’s a skeptic, but I love a challenge 🙂

His first question was typical of insurance folks (especially company folks)- “What’s the return for the time you spend?” He wanted hard dollar figures- cue the fireworks and theme music- “ROI.” And my answer to him was:

It’s not always about ROI.
I don’t think he liked my answer. But I stand firm. I said I don’t really measure at a micro level- such as XYZ post brought in 2 new policies. I know many will argue with me and say, “Carrie, you’re just wasting your time if you’re not measuring exactly how much business is being written.” Your thoughts on that? Agree, disagree- go ahead I can take it.

Sometimes I think just building awareness is enough. It’s about being human, engaging with others, enlightening, educating, showing that you’re a resource. If you do it well enough, people will seek out your services. We live in a shareable society and if you are present where your audience is, letting them know how you can help, they’ll gladly share and respond. You’ll build community that way, and eventually customers. Maybe that sounds too simple, but I honestly don’t think it needs to be complicated. Don’t get me wrong- I do have a focus and a plan for what I do online, but it’s not micromanaged down to each tweet (that’s just not how I work).

Here’s why I think all insurance professionals need to incorporate social media into their marketing plan:

  • The more presence you have online, the more likely you’ll show up near the top of the search engines. My new friend is 100% Internet sales. Don’t you think he has an especially vested interest in this? 
  • You could never afford the amount of advertising that establishing a solid presence on social media can bring. (I can personally speak to this- the above article as well as my recent interview with Insurance Journal are great examples. I couldn’t buy that kind of publicity if I tried.)
  • It is an astounding way to build a network of other insurance professionals. There is strength in numbers, so if you need them to rally for you, they will. If you need to talk ideas and get opinions, you can throw it out there and I guarantee you’ll be amazed by the feedback. It’s unreal and ultimately, very rewarding.
  • It’s becoming a preferred method of conversation/communication with customers. Just this past week, I had two Facebook messages, one from a realtor w/ a question and the other from someone who wanted to set up an appointment to talk about health insurance. You need to be where your customers are. It’s that simple.
And if you’re still not sold? He called me because of the American Agent & Broker article. Why did American Agent & Broker call me? Because of a press release and story I had posted on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn with links back to our website. That could be your next customer.
Talk to me……………….

Filed Under: Digital Marketing, Marketing, Personal Stories, Social Media Tagged With: social media in the insurance industry

Subscribe to get Article Updates delivered directly to your inbox

* = required field

Subscribe to get Article Updates delivered directly to your inbox

* = required field

Connect With Me

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Article Categories

  • Blogging
  • Branding
  • Business Tips
  • Claims
  • Community Building
  • Creating the Customer Experience
  • Digital Marketing
  • Ethics
  • Inspiration & Motivation
  • Inspiration and motivation
  • Insurance
  • Insurance industry commentary
  • Laws and Regulations
  • Marketing
  • Obamacare
  • Ohio Auto insurance
  • Ohio Business Insurance
  • Ohio Health Insurance
  • Ohio Homeowners Insurance
  • Ohio Life Insurance
  • Ohio Medicare Supplement
  • Ohio Motorcycle Insurance
  • Ohio Personal Umbrella Insurance
  • Personal Stories
  • Safety & risk management
  • Sales
  • Social Media
  • Storytelling
  • Video marketing
  • Work-Life Balance
  • Writing a book

Copyright © 2021 · Built by Advisor Evolved